I think my favourite was Sonic 3 or Sonic CD.

Well make your mind up and vote 

I went for Sonic 2, Sonic 1 was great but 2 is better still.

I think my favourite was Sonic 3 or Sonic CD.

Well make your mind up and vote 

I'd have to play them again. I might do though.

For me, it either comes down to Sonic 3 & Knuckles or Sonic CD. I think I'll go with CD, though, because it was actually my first Sonic game. Although 3 came pretty soon afterwards.

I prefer the purity of the original.

I remember Sonic The Fighters being announced for the Sega Saturn and then it never appearing 

Anyone played the arcade version?

I actually never hated that game as much as a lot of Sonic fans seem to. Is it deep? Not really. Is it balanced? Nah. Is it fun? I'd say so!

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_Sz35YqGHZQ

I really need to look into getting the PS3 version, especially since they've made the bosses playable, as well as adding in Honey, who got cut from the original arcade version. Yes, the character from Fighting Vipers. Only she's a cat now. No, I don't get it, either.

I forgot all about Sonic Fighters. Never knew about the arcade release either. I always thought it was a mere concept and nothing more.