Can we ever 'trust' reviews?

Started by Rogue Trooper, June 16, 2013, 15:55:42 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

DreamcastRIP

I think we all know what the score is when it comes to the officially licensed console magazines.  :16:
Owned: Spectrum Jaguar JaguarCD Lynx ST 7800 Dreamcast Saturn MegaDrive Mega-CD 32X Nomad GameGear PS3 PS PSP WiiU Wii GameCube N64 DS, GBm GBA GBC GBP GB VirtualBoy Xbox Vectrex PCE Duo-R 3DO CDi CD32 GX4000 WonderSwan NGPC Gizmondo ColecoVision iPhone PC Mac

TL

Quote from: "DreamcastRIP"I think we all know what the score is when it comes to the officially licensed console magazines.  :16:

Not always, Official Sega Saturn Magazine was excellent!

DreamcastRIP

Quote from: "The Laird"
Quote from: "DreamcastRIP"I think we all know what the score is when it comes to the officially licensed console magazines.  :16:

Not always, Official Sega Saturn Magazine was excellent!

I'm sure it was but I wasn't commenting on the general standard of officially licensed magazines though.
Owned: Spectrum Jaguar JaguarCD Lynx ST 7800 Dreamcast Saturn MegaDrive Mega-CD 32X Nomad GameGear PS3 PS PSP WiiU Wii GameCube N64 DS, GBm GBA GBC GBP GB VirtualBoy Xbox Vectrex PCE Duo-R 3DO CDi CD32 GX4000 WonderSwan NGPC Gizmondo ColecoVision iPhone PC Mac

Rogue Trooper

Quote from: "The Laird"
Quote from: "DreamcastRIP"I think we all know what the score is when it comes to the officially licensed console magazines.  :16:

Not always, Official Sega Saturn Magazine was excellent!

The interviews with likes of AM3, T.T, Lobotomy etc made the magazine stand head and shoulders above the rest.However the magazine often could be it's own worst enemy at times, putting out on-paper tech specs as actual game related performance, saying the game engine powering Sonic World was on par with N64 Super Mario 64 and describing readers as:Tossers, Gibbering fools etc, then there was the bizzare 'war' between them and Sega Power over monthly sales Figures, O.S.M claiming over 39,000 a month compared to Sega Powers 22,000...

And Core Design had seen the Saturn VF3 cart add-on and were so impressed they were planning to make Saturn Tomb Raider II compatible with it Hmmnnn..........

Reviews were usually spot on, but did notice a few oddities now and then:

Tilt score decreased 1 month after original review as whilst Paul Glancey loved it, Rich just did'nt like Pinball games full stop and thought the 2D/3D potential of saturn hardware was wasted on such games and so 'down-graded' score slightly.


They were'nt fans of Rayman either (59%), Shinobi-X only scraped in at 69% yet the horrendous Shellshock scored 73% and Starfighter 3000 (not 2000 as they called it) a mere 72%, but most of the time i could'nt fault the scores or review text.

Still a damn fine magazine and far, far better quality than Off.PS magazine, but then lot of OSM staff were Ex-Mean Machines and it showed in the passion and quality of reviews, not to mention tips, interviews etc.

Rogue Trooper

Thread bump, as previousily was'nt aware of this example from Mean machines....


Basically stumbled across a freebie booklet Emap Images working with their then advertising partner, Virgin Interactive produced (sure Virgin worked hard to get booklet out for the Dec.issue, lol).Nothing too fancy in terms of presentation-so no shinny gold covers or any of that fluff, just a 16 page booklet which promised an 'exclusive review' of Shiny's sensational sequel, Earthworm Jim 2

Inside in-depth look at the games levels, quotes from Shinny regarding making of game etc, as 1 would expect, but back 2 pages sees said review.

Normally such a high profile game would get 2-3 reviewers comments, here, it's just 1 reviewer, Gus who tries to 'gloss over' this fact by saying game is so good, he's not prepared to let anyone else play the game, game goes onto score 95%.

Now, i'm not an EWJ fan, so score is meanigless to me, it's this hogwash about why only 1 reviewer and why review done in this booklet.

As we all know, magazines past+present cannot survive on newstand sales+subscriptions alone, no escaping that fact, probably around since the stone tablet days, but please, do not insult your readership's intelligence by trying to gloss-over the fact advertising revenue is essential and the publishers of both game+magazine are working together on joint venture to promote their own self interests.

This was the only such example i know of from Mean Machines and honestly surprised to see it, but it's something more active today than ever it seems as is the B.s put across from publishing groups of magazines i buy.

i know they need to work closely with advertisers, but had i read this 'review' at the time, would i trust Gus and his opinions on future reviews? no, i honestly would'nt.The booklet would have worked far better as just a making of..EWJ 2 than having the 'review' in.

Publishing house management, editors etc should really be careful how they promote advertising deals like these, it often leaves them wide open.

Maybe a future interview with Mean Machines staff and or Virgin could throw some light on this?.

sloan

I mostly take written or video game reviews with a cautious eye/ear. I usually like lots of images/video to get a better idea. This is because I mainly use reviews for purchasing ideas. I realize that we each have differing opinions, reviewers included. This way, I get a general feel for a game from the review. That, coupled with the images/video helps me to decide whether to purchase or not. Sometimes, if possible, I will seek out as many reviews for a game to get a more averaging effect from the various reviewers. I always try to be careful to not let one overtly negative review skew my own judgment because my personality is that I like many games that others seem to hate.

SnakeEyes

I tend to take reviews with a grain of salt as so many factors are in play.

Its the internet reviews on small sites that I just totally ignore to be honest. Much worse than any magazine. usually so much bias, and hidden agendas.

I went on a site once where every PS1 version of a games scored 2 or 3 points higher than the saturn and n64 versions every single time. It was obvious the site had a heavy PS1 bias. how can you trust any reviewer that cant be objective.

Greyfox

In all the 32 years gaming and with all the magazine coverage I've read throughout he decades, I was rarely ever taken in by game reviewers simply because they weren't me and could not tell me how I would feel about any game I'd played or not, I would base some of the reviews parsing little tit bits the reviewer found in the game that would interest me.

But ever since forever, I have always waited to play the games myself with my own judgement and never relied on others, so for me it would be more a case see what I think, than trusting a game review or basing my opinion of their views.

Some people rely on game reviewers, some of us don't, and I am one of those people.